The Boundaries of Chaplain Confidentiality

“A lady was in a room of her unwell baby when she was frequented by a civilian clinic chaplain. She explained to the chaplain a number of points about herself and her family members, which includes the fact that she was expecting. The following working day she was taken aback when a nurse approached her and inquired about her pregnancy. It turned out that significantly of what she experienced talked about with the chaplain was prepared down in her child’s professional medical chart… ” 1

Traditionally, customers of the clergy have had a moral obligation to sustain the confidentiality of their congregants. In new a long time, even so, persons have introduced an improved selection of lawsuits towards pastors for invasion of privateness arising out of the disclosure of confidential info. The end result of these suits has introduced recognition that the obligation to retain confidentiality is not only a moral obligation, but also frequently a authorized a single.2

If civilians count on their discussions with clergy to be confidential, this presumption is even better in the army group the place practices like necessary drug screening and gate automobile queries add to a greater sensitivity to privacy difficulties. While religious denominations have their possess rules that tutorial their clergy in regard to details shared below several situations, various Guidelines, Regulations and the Manuel for Courts-Martial (MCM) have statutes that secure the confidentiality of communications with armed forces chaplains.

Preserving our privileged situation

The lawful protection available by civilian lawful units and the armed service program differs considerably. While navy members as citizens of the United States are both matter to and gain from federal and point out regulations, they are also subject to the UCMJ and other distinct army rules. In specific situations involving communications, military rules and rules just take priority over civilian guidelines.

According to Navy Regulations of Proof MRE 503(b) (2), in buy for a interaction to be viewed as privileged, three conditions must be met:

1. It should be made “either as a official act of faith or a subject of conscience.”
2. The communication must be manufactured to a chaplain in his or her job as chaplain or to his/her assistant in an official ability.
3. It is the intent of the communicator that the information be confidential.

It is very clear that it is the intent of the particular person building the communication and not that of the chaplain that is critical. It is also very clear that the applicability of the privilege, that is, regardless of whether or not the interaction is to be viewed as private, is decided by the intention of the bash and not the put the place the conversation usually takes area. (e.g. chaplain’s office environment, healthcare facility room, aboard ship, or in the subject.)

Even with obvious insurance policies and regulations upholding confidentiality on the element of military chaplains, in a recent 2013 poll of naval personnel, 63 p.c of 5.049 respondents did not imagine their communications with chaplains have been private, and 65 % of 2,895 respondents erroneously thought that Navy chaplains are required to report sure matters to the command.3

Historic viewpoint

Before searching exclusively at the follow of armed forces chaplains earning entries into patients’ health-related information, it would be beneficial to search at how this apply has progressed in current record.

Healthcare facility chaplaincy as a unique career in the United States around the earlier 20-30 years has assumed a additional proactive stance toward individuals, healthcare pros, and health care amenities. As opposed to in the earlier exactly where people usually received pastoral visits from clergy symbolizing particular religion groups, right now a expert cadre of certified clinic chaplains has evolved who are users of the healthcare group entire with obtain to patients’ clinical data both equally to collect facts and to make notations of their possess.

Though worthy strides have been produced to integrate chaplains more entirely into the health care procedure, some health care ethicists think about charting, i.e. generating notations in patients’ medical information accessible to other folks by this specialized chaplaincy as “disquieting” and recommend there exists a want to reassess experienced commitments “to respect and secure the bio-psycho-social integrity of people.”4 The evolution of medical center chaplaincy as a profession distinctive from congregational based ministry has also raised concern among the some customers of the clergy who perspective procedures like charting as a risk to confidentiality that has been a cornerstone of their ministry.

Chaplains, health care documents and confidentiality

Despite the fact that BUMEDINST 1730.2A makes an attempt to balance the hospital’s require for scientific facts and the patient’s have to have for private treatment, paragraph 12b of the Instruction reads: “Patients really should be suggested that sure details communicated to the chaplain could be shared with other associates of the treatment method crew or in a medical supervisory session unless of course the client exclusively requests that this kind of details continue to be in assurance with the chaplain.”

If armed forces patients presume that what they go over with clinic chaplains “may perhaps be shared” with others until they “specially request that these details keep on being in confidence,” could these similar services associates be misled to believe that this also applies to what they share with chaplains exterior of medical services? Could possibly these same support adult men and women be led to concern that what they focus on with their device chaplains may possibly be shared with their command unless they “particularly ask for that such info keep on being in self-confidence”?

Alternatively than telling sufferers their communications with chaplains may perhaps be shared with other people until they “especially” ask for that these types of info continue to be private, I post it would be extra in preserving with SECNAVINST 1730.9 (“Private Communications to Chaplains”) to revise BUMED Instruction to browse, “Data shared with chaplains is presumed confidential until the affected individual especially requests the chaplain share specific details with other users of the medical workforce.”

The point that lots of individuals might be suffering from abnormal actual physical or psychological suffering may possibly affect not only their potential to make informed conclusions relating to disclosure, but also affect their ability “to distinguish private communications from general pastoral treatment interventions” as observed in the recent BUMED Instruction.

Hospital non secular assessments

A quantity of armed service hospital chaplains nowadays are making an attempt to make religious assessments of a patient’s cultural, religious, spiritual beliefs or practices, the outcomes of which are frequently recorded in the patient’s medical document. Such a apply can be problematic in the military services where by the privateness of staff and their family associates are shielded as in the circumstance of SECNAVINST 1730.9, paragraph 4 (h):

Documents or notes compiled by a chaplain in his/her counseling obligations are considered ‘work product’ and confidential. As this kind of, chaplains must safeguard any these types of documents, in whichever medium or structure, containing confidential interaction. When no more time wanted, these perform merchandise will be wrecked.

Not like “notes” a chaplain may possibly acquire in his/her business that are later on destroyed, the “notes” a healthcare facility chaplain may well chart in the course of action of undertaking a spiritual evaluation continue being a portion of the patient’s health care document even immediately after the affected person is discharged. Chaplains who are compelled by supervisors or hospital administrators to justify their function or “competency” by charting spiritual assessments could potentially weaken the believe in that demands to exist among clergy and the people today to whom they minister. People who also use the program of charting for skilled validation, credentialing, or in purchase to justify work, potentially redefine the pastoral go to from selfless to self-serving. On top of that, it has yet to be recognized if health-related healthcare teams significantly advantage from these types of a hugely subjective intake which is principally helpful to the affected individual.

Just one also might note that spiritual care by the chaplain is not so substantially an “intervention” (as mentioned in BUMEDINST 1730.2A, paragraph 13a), or one thing to “repair” but much more of a relational manner of staying. The non secular lifestyle is a relational life involving how the affected person relates to others and how she or he understands their present situations in the context of a individual belief system. Since clinic chaplains almost never have very long term associations with individuals who both are discharged or die, these assessments and interventions may perhaps not confirm to be the truest reflection of the person in query.

The role a chaplain plays in the healthcare neighborhood can not be underestimated. Although metrics are significantly utilized inside clinical institutions as a technique for examining the worth and requirement of professional positions and the variety of billets, there are a host of intangible rewards a chaplain delivers to patient visitation that can never be measured by tactics like charting alone.

Service associates and their people should have the best assurance that their conversations will be honored and guarded. Navy chaplains have to vigilantly insure their charting techniques do not “cross the line” lest they surrender this sacred part that has been entrusted to them for above two centuries of U.S. naval historical past.

Lieutenant Commander Gomulka was a team chaplain at Naval Health-related Center San Diego. She retired in August of 2014 following the article appeared in the December 2013 edition of Proceedings posted by the Naval Institute Push.

1. Jami Briton, “Hospital Chaplains Not Demanded to Keep Details Private,” KCRG-Tv set9 Information Report (April 15, 2010).
2. David O. Middlebrook, “Pastoral Confidentiality: An Moral and Authorized Obligation,” Enrichment Journal (Spring 2010).
3. Lifelink Publication, Vol., 2, Challenge 6, OPNAV N171, June 2013.
4. Roberta Springer Loewy and Erich H. Loewy, “Healthcare and the Hospital Chaplain,” Medscape Standard Medication (March 14, 2007).

Read Next